Saturday, September 7, 2013

Dora Learns to Write

In Pat Cordiero’s article, “Dora Learns to Write and Encounter Punctuation,” Cordiero addresses a situation in which a teacher helps a students learn to write (ADD TITLE TO PAPER). Although it seemed that Dora’s teacher had a passive style of teaching punctuation/writing, it allowed Dora the freedom to experiment and slowly begin to grasp the concept herself.  The teacher did a great job of encouraging the student without making her feel inadequate. She never questioned Dora’s methods directly or told her she was wrong; instead, she slowly introduced new ideas. Each day she pointed out something new for Dora to focus on. She encouraged Dora to read out loud and notice when she dropped her voice. When this made Dora put a period at the end of a clause, the teacher didn’t correct her because she could see this was the start of Dora understanding when to use a period. Allowing Dora to come up with her own hypothesis, gave Dora the opportunity to understand and develop the concept rather than just be told the concept. She points out places where Dora does well in her work, which then encourages Dora to discover where it feels right to put a period. Dora, WHOSE writing is just developing, learns something new each time she experiments with her punctuation (POSSESSIVE PRONOUN). Her introduction to the concept of a sentence and a period was very short and sweet. She used her hands to try and frame a sentence and taught students to pause every time they see a period in a piece of writing. This gets them to focus on the idea of what a sentence sounds like so they can begin to play with the idea in their own work.
The teacher never criticizes Dora’s attempts at period use; never does she make her feel dumb for experimenting with her punctuation.  The teacher never acts displeased with Dora’s work; instead, she encourages her to experiment and praises her for the attempts she is making with her writing. She doesn’t give the students a hand out, or give them a list of rules of what makes a sentence; she instead allows them to think on their own.

Dora struggles to find when to use a comma because speech and writing are two different concepts. Although she is able to speak well, she is a new writer and writing is a language all of ITS own (POSSESSIVE PRONOUN). Speaking aloud does not give a clear indication of when a sentence ends, so a period is a whole new concept. When Dora learns she needs to separate her words, she starts putting a period after every word in order to emphasize the separation. This makes sense because she is realizing that a period is used as a marker to end something. Because she is new to writing, it is going to take her awhile to figure out when it is the appropriate time to use a period to mark the end of a sentence. It is a hard concept to grasp, especially since a place where a comma would go sounds very similar to the end of a sentence to a new writer. Dora’s teacher offers a good approach to teaching writing, although YOURS might differ, her approach worked because it allowed Dora to understand versus memorize a concept (POSSESSIVE PRONOUN).

Sunday, August 25, 2013

MY GOALS



After looking through the course pack, I realized there are lots of small and odd grammar rules that I have yet to master. When looking at my own work, the most common mistake seems to be run-on sentences and comma splices. I don’t see any in my more creative writing pieces, but in my essays I seem to want to cram too much information into one sentence. In most cases, I am either trying to connect too much or trying too hard to make the sentence sound artistic.

Although I fully understand what a comma splice is, I still seem to do them without thinking about it. Usually I catch most of them while I’m editing, but a few still seem to slip through. I often have sentences that are grammatically correct, but they are just too long to be effective. Listed below are a couple examples of run on sentences and/or comma splices I identified in my writing.   

Despite being trapped, the cage bird continues to sing, for it has hope that one day it to can taste the freedom, such as the slaves continued to sing and hope for the day they could put slavery behind them.

The sentence above needs to be two sentences. In my head I saw the connection between each phrase, however, there are too many topics being addressed. By breaking it into two sentences, I would make my meaning more clear.

In an attempt to connect all my ideas, I SACRIFICE STRUCTURE, ORGANIZATION, FLUENCY, ETC. [series of nouns connected with commas and no and’s]. In my desire to create a flow of connected ideas, I instead create a jumble of ideas. I focus too much on trying to sound artistic and end up messing up the basic structure of a sentence in order to achieve my goal.

Often times I think I am trying to state something basic and then try and connect multiple ideas to that basic idea all in one sentence. Instead of portraying my connections, I end up sounding disorganized and I take away from the importance of each idea. If I want to be ORGANIZED AND ARTISTIC AND BE GRAMMATICALLY CORRECT [series of nouns connected with and’s and no commas], I need to be more creative with my sentence structure. I do tend to use semicolons often, which stems from my desire to connect my ideas. However, although I use them correctly, I often don’t use them as much as I should.

Gilpin argues that the difference between the beautiful and picturesque is that beautiful has no roughness or spirit about it, it is simply there, giving beauty to a form. The image of the creek poses no further insight than what it is, there is no ruin or curiosities about it, it simply is what it is. 

Above is an example of me using commas when I should have been using semicolons. I tend to like to repeat a phrase of structure for emphasis, but in this case when I repeat the word it I am choosing not to add a connecting word and therefore need to use a semicolon to connect the two ideas.